Pedophile Priests Shown Sympathy in South American Drama


The Club
(El Club)

DVD Review by Kam Williams

Pedophile Priests Shown Sympathy in South American Drama

The Oscar-winning Best Picture Spotlight addressed the problem of pedophilia in the priesthood from the point of view of the victims. But if you’re looking for a take on the issue more sympathetic The Club, El Club, DVD Review by Kam Williams, Pedophile Priests, South Americato the perpetrators, have I got a movie for you.

Nominated for a Golden Globe in the Best Foreign Language Film category, The Club is a disturbing, deliberately-paced drama for the very open-minded directed by Pablo Larrain (Post Mortem). The picture is set at a mountaintop estate nestled along the Chilean seacoast where a half-dozen defrocked clergymen have been sent to repent.

The secluded retreat is run with a firm hand by Sister Monica (Antonia Zegers), a disgraced nun with a checkered past of her own. Nevertheless. it’s her job to enforce house rules dictated by the Vatican including no communication with outsiders, no cell phones, no self-pleasuring, no self-flagellation, and a vow of poverty.

Consequently, the former pastors’ Spartan-like daily regime consists of little more than chores, attending mass, confessing their sins and praying the rosary between meals. Still, there is much to be gleaned from the clerics’ conversations among themselves.

This one feigns innocence, claiming, “I didn’t commit a crime. I’m not a queer.” Another, ostensibly wracked with guilt, eventually finds a gun and shoots himself in the head, when he can no longer live with himself. And there’s an unrepentant soul who says “I see the light of the Lord in homosexuality,” arguing that man-boy love brings one closer to God than heterosexuality.   

Rules are made to be broken, and the plot thickens when a housemate sneaks into town where he forges a friendship with a fellow pederast offering to procure all the local kids he’d like to rape. Will he or won’t he take the creep up on the offer?

An eerily-unsettling examination of pedophilia from the perspective of the perpetrators   suggesting that these sex offenders might not be monsters, but merely misunderstood children of God.

Very Good (3 stars)


In Spanish with subtitles

Running time: 97 minutes

Distributor: Music Box Films

DVD Extras: Commentary by co-stars Alfredo Castro and Antonia Zegers; interviews with Antonia Zegers and director Pablo Larrain; Berlinale press conference excerpt; and a collector’s booklet featuring cast and crews interviews and an essay by film critic Jessica Kiang.

To order a copy of The Club on DVD, visit:

Source:  Baret News


Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial